Michael Wood
Here below, we have the entire interview between the American journalist Carlson and the President of Russia, directly from the Russian President’s website and attested by a Russian speaking English researcher as being complete from the video interview.
Putin speaks without notes or cue board, although obviously the questions either specifically or generally would have been known by him in advance as is normal in interviews with all government heads around the world.
In my view, Putin comes off as a highly intelligent, well educated man who is very cautious in his behaviour.ย ย This is no wild-eyed dictator intent on invading the rest of Europe.
We need to keep in mind something that was carefully hidden from us by our own governments for forty years:ย Theย Soviet and now Russian Federation army was never designed for offence:ย It was deliberately designed for defence of the borders of metropolitan Russia.ย ย The Communists obviously wanted a communist world and were more than willing to spread their ideology far and wide, but certainly once nuclear weapons were possessed by the Soviet Union, Britain and America, war was unimaginable because mutually assured destruction was seen to be obvious to both sides.
The modern Russian Federation is not the Soviet Union reborn.ย That fact needs to be fully absorbed.ย It really has transformed itself over the past thirty-five years into an essentially Christian nation with an ancient national Church which is far larger than the entire world-wide Anglican Communion and structured not that dissimilarily from the Church of England, but not written into their constitution โ it is not government supported.ย This is their Christian national replacement for communism and it is not spread by war.ย ย PresidentPutin and his deputy Dmitry Medvedev are both active members of that Russian Orthodox Church.
The point is that modern Russia is simply not interested in stepping outside its borders.ย The question is where those borders are.ย The Russians consider their natural border in the Ukraine as being the Dneipr River (aqs can be seen from Putin’s comments below).ย Beyond that, they are not interested and tend to regard western Ukrain as essentially Polish and Hungarian (did you know that in south-west Ukraine, the Hungarian language is widespread and the people largely consider themselves to be Hungarian?).
I think this interview to be essentially a calming point.ย It proves to the intelligent and unbiased observer that there is a way of stopping the idiotic advance to a European war.
The question to my mind is: Why on earth are European governments (and our own) telling their people to prepare for a forthcoming war with Russia?ย Is it nothing more that an almost diabolic attempt to draw our attention away from the dire straits of our Euro/UK economies, our huge debt load, the moslem soft invasion, and the increasingly obvious incompetence of our parliamentary โleadersโ?
Read this interview carefully.ย Understand Putin’s history lesson and understand how it points to an end to the Ukraine war;ย It can be stopped in one of two ways:ย A negotiated peace right now or when the Russian army reaches the Dneipr.ย Personally, the way that NATO European/UK governments/ Zelenskyy are behaving, I think the latter is the more likely.
Interview withย President Vladimir Putin
Vladimir Putin answered questions from Tucker Carlson, aย journalist andย founder ofย Tucker Carlson Network.
February 9, 2024
07:00
Theย Kremlin, Moscow
Tucker Carlson: Mr. President, thank you.
Onย Februaryย 22, 2022, you addressed your country inย your nationwide address when theย conflict inย Ukraine started andย you said that you were acting because you had come toย theย conclusion that theย United States through NATO might initiate aย quote, โsurprise attack onย our countryโ. Andย toย American ears that sounds paranoid. Tell us why you believe theย United States might strike Russia out ofย theย blue. How did you conclude that?
Vladimir Putin: It’s not that theย United States was going toย launch aย surprise strike onย Russia, Iย didn’t say so. Are we having aย talk show orย serious conversation?
Tucker Carlson: That was aย good quote. Thank you, itโs formidably serious!
Vladimir Putin: You were initially trained inย history, asย far asย Iย know?
Tucker Carlson: Yes.
Vladimir Putin: So if you donโt mind Iย will take only 30 seconds orย one minute ofย your time forย giving you aย little historical background.
Tucker Carlson: Please.
Interview toย Tucker Carlson. Part 1
Vladimir Putin: Letโs look where our relationship with Ukraine started from. Where does Ukraine come from?
Theย Russian state started toย exist asย aย centralized state inย 862. This is considered toย be theย year ofย creation ofย theย Russian state because this year theย townspeople ofย Novgorod (aย city inย theย North-West ofย theย country) invited Rurik, aย Varangian prince from Scandinavia, toย reign. Inย 1862, Russia celebrated theย 1000thย anniversary ofย its statehood, andย inย Novgorod there is aย memorial dedicated toย theย 1000thย anniversary ofย theย country.
Inย 882, Rurik’s successor Prince Oleg, who was, actually, playing theย role ofย regent atย Rurik’s young son because Rurik had died byย that time, came toย Kiev. He ousted two brothers who, apparently, had once been members ofย Rurik’s squad. So, Russia began toย develop with two centers ofย power, Kiev andย Novgorod.
Theย next, very significant date inย theย history ofย Russia, was 988. This was theย Baptism ofย Russia, when Prince Vladimir, theย great-grandson ofย Rurik, baptized Russia andย adopted Orthodoxy, orย Eastern Christianity. From this time theย centralized Russian state began toย strengthen. Why? Because ofย aย single territory, integrated economic ties, one andย theย same language and, after theย Baptism ofย Russia, theย same faith andย rule ofย theย Prince. Theย centralized Russian state began toย take shape.
Back inย theย Middle Ages, Prince Yaroslav theย Wise introduced theย order ofย succession toย theย throne, but after he passed away, it became complicated forย various reasons. Theย throne was passed not directly from father toย eldest son, but from theย prince who had passed away toย his brother, then toย his sons inย different lines. All this led toย theย fragmentation andย theย end ofย Rus asย aย single state. There was nothing special about it, theย same was happening then inย Europe. But theย fragmented Russian state became anย easy prey toย theย empire created earlier byย Genghis Khan. His successors, namely, Batu Khan, came toย Rus, plundered andย ruined nearly all theย cities. Theย southern part, including Kiev, byย theย way, andย some other cities, simply lost independence, while northern cities preserved some ofย their sovereignty. They had toย pay tribute toย theย Horde, but they managed toย preserve some part ofย their sovereignty. Andย then aย unified Russian state began toย take shape with its centre inย Moscow.
Theย southern part ofย theย Russian lands, including Kiev, began toย gradually gravitate towards another โmagnetโย โ theย centre that was emerging inย Europe. This was theย Grand Duchy ofย Lithuania. It was even called theย Lithuanian-Russian Duchy, because Russians were aย significant part ofย its population. They spoke theย Old Russian language andย were Orthodox. But then there was aย unification, theย union ofย theย Grand Duchy ofย Lithuania andย theย Kingdom ofย Poland. Aย few years later, another union was signed, but this time already inย theย religious sphere. Some ofย theย Orthodox priests became subordinate toย theย Pope. Thus, these lands became part ofย theย Polish-Lithuanian state.
During decades, theย Poles were engaged inย theย โPolonizationโ ofย this part ofย theย population: they introduced their language there, tried toย entrench theย idea that this population was not exactly Russians, that because they lived onย theย fringe (u kraya) they were โUkrainiansโ. Originally, theย word โUkrainianโ meant that aย person was living onย theย outskirts ofย theย state, near theย fringe, orย was engaged inย border service. It didn’t mean any particular ethnic group.
So, theย Poles were trying inย every possible way toย polonize this part ofย theย Russian lands andย actually treated it rather harshly, not toย say cruelly. All that led toย theย fact that this part ofย theย Russian lands began toย struggle forย their rights. They wrote letters toย Warsaw demanding that their rights be observed andย that people be commissioned here, including toย Kievโฆ
Interview toย Tucker Carlson. Part 2
Tucker Carlson: Iย beg your pardon, can you tell us what periodโฆ Iย am losing track ofย where inย history we are?
Vladimir Putin: It was inย theย 13thย century.
Now Iย will tell what happened later andย give theย dates so that there is no confusion. Andย inย 1654, even aย bit earlier, theย people who were inย control ofย theย authority over that part ofย theย Russian lands, addressed Warsaw, Iย repeat, demanding their rights be observed that they send toย them rulers ofย Russian origin andย Orthodox faith. When Warsaw did not answer them andย inย fact rejected their demands, they turned toย Moscow so that Moscow took them away.
So that you don’t think that Iย am inventing thingsโฆ I’ll give you these documentsโฆ
Tucker Carlson: It doesnโt sound like you are inventing it, but Iย am not sure why itโs relevant toย whatโs happened two years ago.
Vladimir Putin: But still, these are documents from theย archives, copies. Here are letters from Bogdan Khmelnitsky, theย man who then controlled theย power inย this part ofย theย Russian lands that is now called Ukraine. He wrote toย Warsaw demanding that their rights be upheld, andย after being refused, he began toย write letters toย Moscow asking toย take them under theย strong hand ofย theย Moscow Tsar. There are copies ofย these documents. Iย will leave them forย your good memory. There is aย translation into Russian, you can translate it into English later.
Russia would not agree toย admit them straight away, assuming this would trigger aย war with Poland. Nevertheless, inย 1654, theย Zemsky Sobor, which was aย representative body ofย power ofย theย Old Russian state, made theย decision: thoseย Old Russian lands became part ofย theย Tsardom ofย Muscovy.
Asย expected, theย war with Poland began. It lasted 13 years, andย then aย truce was concluded. Inย all, after that act ofย 1654, 32 years later, Iย think, aย peace treaty with Poland was concluded, โtheย eternal peace,โ asย it said. Andย those lands, theย whole left bank ofย theย Dnieper, including Kiev, reverted toย Russia, whileย theย entire right bank ofย theย Dnieper remained inย possession ofย Poland.
Under theย rule ofย Catherine theย Great, Russia reclaimed all ofย its historical lands, including inย theย south andย west. This all lasted until theย Revolution. Before World War I, Austrian General Staff relied onย theย ideas ofย Ukrainianization andย started actively promoting theย ideas ofย Ukraine andย theย Ukrainianization. Their motive was obvious. Just before World War Iย they wanted toย weaken theย potential enemy andย secure themselves favourable conditions inย theย border area. So theย idea which had emerged inย Poland that people residing inย that territory were allegedly not really Russians, but rather belonged toย aย special ethnic group, Ukrainians, started being propagated byย theย Austrian General Staff.
Asย far back asย theย 19th century, theorists calling forย Ukrainian independence appeared. All those, however, claimed that Ukraine should have aย very good relationship with Russia. They insisted onย that. After theย 1917 Revolution, theย Bolsheviks sought toย restore theย statehood, andย theย Civil War began, including theย hostilities with Poland. Inย 1921, peace with Poland was proclaimed, andย under that treaty, theย right bank ofย theย Dnieper River once again was given back toย Poland.
Inย 1939, after Poland cooperated with Hitlerย โ it did collaborate with Hitler, you knowย โHitler offered Poland peace andย aย treaty ofย friendship andย alliance (we have all theย relevant documents inย theย archives), demanding inย return that Poland give back toย Germany theย so-called Danzig Corridor, which connected theย bulk ofย Germany with East Prussia andย Konigsberg. After World War Iย this territory was transferred toย Poland, andย instead ofย Danzig, aย city ofย Gdansk emerged. Hitler asked them toย give it amicably, but they refused. Still they collaborated with Hitler andย engaged together inย theย partitioning ofย Czechoslovakia.
Tucker Carlson: May Iย askโฆ You are making theย case that Ukraine, certain parts ofย Ukraine, Eastern Ukraine, inย fact, has been Russia forย hundreds ofย years, why wouldnโt you just take it when you became President 24 years ago? Your have nuclear weapons, they donโt. Itโs actually your land. Why did you wait so long?
Vladimir Putin: Iโll tell you. Iโm coming toย that. This briefing is coming toย anย end. It might be boring, but it explains many things.
Tucker Carlson: Itโs not boring.
Vladimir Putin: Good. Good. Iย am so gratified that you appreciate that. Thank you.
So before World War II, Poland collaborated with Hitler andย although it did not yield toย Hitlerโs demands, it still participated inย theย partitioning ofย Czechoslovakia together with Hitler. Asย theย Poles had not given theย Danzig Corridor toย Germany, andย went too far, pushing Hitler toย start World War II byย attacking them. Why was it Poland against whom theย war started onย 1 September 1939? Poland turned out toย be uncompromising, andย Hitler had nothing toย do but start implementing his plans with Poland.
Byย theย way, theย USSRย โ Iย have read some archive documentsย โ behaved very honestly. It asked Polandโs permission toย transit its troops through theย Polish territory toย help Czechoslovakia. But theย then Polish foreign minister said that if theย Soviet planes flew over Poland, they would be downed over theย territory ofย Poland. But that doesnโt matter. What matters is that theย war began, andย Poland fell prey toย theย policies it had pursued against Czechoslovakia, asย under theย well-known Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, part ofย that territory, including western Ukraine, was toย be given toย Russia. Thus Russia, which was then named theย USSR, regained its historical lands.
After theย victory inย theย Great Patriotic War, asย we call World War II, all those territories were ultimately enshrined asย belonging toย Russia, toย theย USSR. Asย forย Poland, it received, apparently inย compensation, theย lands which had originally being German: theย eastern parts ofย Germany (these are now western lands ofย Poland). Ofย course, Poland regained access toย theย Baltic sea, andย Danzig, which was once again given its Polish name. So this was how this situation developed.
Inย 1922, when theย USSR was being established, theย Bolsheviks started building theย USSR andย established theย Soviet Ukraine, which had never existed before.
Tucker Carlson: Right.
Vladimir Putin: Stalin insisted that those republics be included inย theย USSR asย autonomous entities. Forย some inexplicable reason, Lenin, theย founder ofย theย Soviet state, insisted that they be entitled toย withdraw from theย USSR. And, again forย some unknown reasons, he transferred toย that newly established Soviet Republic ofย Ukraine some ofย theย lands together with people living there, even though those lands had never been called Ukraine; andย yet they were made part ofย that Soviet Republic ofย Ukraine. Those lands included theย Black Sea region, which was received under Catherine theย Great andย which had no historical connection with Ukraine whatsoever.
Even if we go asย far back asย 1654, when these lands returned toย theย Russian Empire, that territory was theย size ofย three toย four regions ofย modern Ukraine, with no Black Sea region. That was completely out ofย theย question.
Tucker Carlson: Inย 1654?
Vladimir Putin: Exactly.
Tucker Carlson: You have, Iย see, encyclopedic knowledge ofย this region. But why didnโt you make this case forย theย first 22 years asย president, that Ukraine wasnโt aย real country?
Vladimir Putin: Theย Soviet Ukraine was given aย great deal ofย territory that had never belonged toย it, including theย Black Sea region. Atย some point, when Russia received them asย anย outcome ofย theย Russo-Turkish wars, they were called โNew Russiaโ orย Novorossiya. But that does not matter. What matters is that Lenin, theย founder ofย theย Soviet State, established Ukraine that way. Forย decades, theย Ukrainian Soviet Republic developed asย part ofย theย USSR, andย forย unknown reasons again, theย Bolsheviks were engaged inย Ukrainianization. It was not merely because theย Soviet leadership was composed toย aย great extent ofย those originating from Ukraine. Rather, it was explained byย theย general policy ofย indigenization pursued byย theย Soviet Union. Same things were done inย other Soviet republics. This involved promoting national languages andย national cultures, which is not bad inย principle. That is how theย Soviet Ukraine was created.
After World War II, Ukraine received, inย addition toย theย lands that had belonged toย Poland before theย war, part ofย theย lands that had previously belonged toย Hungary andย Romania (today known asย Western Ukraine). So Romania andย Hungary had some ofย their lands taken away andย given toย theย Ukraine andย they still remain part ofย Ukraine. So inย this sense, we have every reason toย affirm that Ukraine is anย artificial state that was shaped atย Stalinโs will.
Tucker Carlson: Do you believe Hungary has aย right toย take back its land from Ukraine? Andย that other nations have aย right toย go back toย their 1654 borders?
Vladimir Putin: Iย am not sure whether they should go back toย theย 1654 borders, but given Stalinโs time, so-called Stalinโs regimeย โ which asย many claim saw numerous violations ofย human rights andย violations ofย theย rights ofย other statesย โ one may say that they could claim back those lands ofย theirs, while having no right toย do that, it is atย least understandableโฆ
Tucker Carlson: Have you told Viktor Orbรกn that he can have aย part ofย Ukraine?
Vladimir Putin: Never. Iย have never told him. Not aย single time. We have not even had any conversation onย that, but Iย actually know forย sure that Hungarians who live there wanted toย get back toย their historical land.
Moreover, Iย would like toย share aย very interesting story with you, I’ll digress, it’s aย personal one. Somewhere inย theย early 80’s, Iย went onย aย road trip onย aย car from then-Leningrad (now St. Petersburg) across theย Soviet Union through Kiev, made aย stop inย Kiev, andย then went toย Western Ukraine. Iย went toย theย town ofย Beregovoye, andย all theย names ofย towns andย villages there were inย Russian andย inย aย language Iย didn’t understandย โ inย Hungarian . Inย Russian andย inย Hungarian. Not inย Ukrainianย โ inย Russian andย inย Hungarian.
Iย was driving through some kind ofย aย village andย there were men sitting next toย theย houses andย they were wearing black three-piece suits andย black cylinder hats. Iย asked, โAre they some kind ofย entertainers?โ Iย was told, โNo, they’re not entertainers. They’re Hungarians. โIย said, โWhat are they doing here?โย โ โWhat do you mean? This is their land, they live here.โ This was during theย Soviet time, inย theย 1980โs. They preserve theย Hungarian language, Hungarian names, andย all their national costumes. They are Hungarians andย they feel themselves toย be Hungarians. Andย ofย course, when now there is anย infringementโฆ.
Tucker Carlson: Andย thereโs aย lot ofย that though, Iย think. Many nations feel upset aboutย โ there are Transylvanians asย well asย you, others, you knowย โ but many nations feel frustrated byย their re-drawn borders after theย wars ofย theย 20thย century, andย wars going back aย thousand years, theย ones that you mention, but theย fact is that you didnโt make this case inย public until two years ago inย February, andย inย theย case that you made, which Iย read today, you explain aย great length that you thought aย physical threat from theย West andย NATO, including potentially aย nuclear threat, andย thatโs what got you toย move. Is that aย fair characterization ofย what you said?
Vladimir Putin: Iย understand that myย long speeches probably fall outside ofย theย genre ofย anย interview. That is why Iย asked you atย theย beginning: โAre we going toย have aย serious talk orย aย show?โ You saidย โ aย serious talk. So bear with me please.
We are coming toย theย point where theย Soviet Ukraine was established. Then, inย 1991, theย Soviet Union collapsed. Andย everything that Russia had generously bestowed onย Ukraine was โdragged awayโ byย theย latter.
I’m coming toย aย very important point ofย today’s agenda. After all, theย collapse ofย theย Soviet Union was effectively initiated byย theย Russian leadership. Iย do not understand what theย Russian leadership was guided byย atย theย time, but Iย suspect there were several reasons toย think everything would be fine.
First, Iย think that theย then Russian leadership believed that theย fundamentals ofย theย relationship between Russia andย Ukraine were: inย fact, aย common languageย โ more than 90 percent ofย theย population there spoke Russian; family tiesย โ every third person there had some kind ofย family orย friendship ties; common culture; common history; finally, common faith; co-existence within aย single state forย centuries; andย deeply interconnected economies. All ofย these were so fundamental. All these elements together make our good relations inevitable.
Theย second point is aย very important one. Iย want you asย anย American citizen andย your viewers toย hear about this asย well. Theย former Russian leadership assumed that theย Soviet Union had ceased toย exist andย therefore there were no longer any ideological dividing lines. Russia even agreed, voluntarily andย proactively, toย theย collapse ofย theย Soviet Union andย believed that this would be understood byย theย so-called (now inย scare quotes) โcivilized Westโ asย anย invitation forย cooperation andย associateship. That is what Russia was expecting both from theย United States andย theย so-called collective West asย aย whole.
There were smart people, including inย Germany. Egon Bahr, aย major politician ofย theย Social Democratic Party, who insisted inย his personal conversations with theย Soviet leadership onย theย brink ofย theย collapse ofย theย Soviet Union that aย new security system should be established inย Europe. Help should be given toย unify Germany, but aย new system should also be established toย include theย United States, Canada, Russia, andย other Central European countries. But NATO needs not toย expand. That’s what he said: if NATO expands, everything would be just theย same asย during theย Cold War, only closer toย Russia’s borders. That’s all. He was aย wise old man, but no one listened toย him. Inย fact, he got angry once (we have aย record ofย this conversation inย our archives): โIf, he said, you don’t listen toย me, I’m never setting myย foot inย Moscow once again.โ He was frustrated with theย Soviet leadership. He was right, everything happened just asย he had said.
Tucker Carlson: Well, ofย course, it did come true, andย youโve mentioned it many times. Iย think, itโs aย fair point. Andย many inย America thought that relations between Russia andย United States would be fine after theย collapse ofย theย Soviet Union, atย theย core. But theย opposite happened. But have never explained why you think that happened, except toย say that theย West fears aย strong Russia. But we have aย strong China that theย West doesnโt seem toย be very afraid of. What about Russia, what do you think convinced theย policymakers toย take it down?
Vladimir Putin: Theย West is afraid ofย aย strong China more than it fears aย strong Russia because Russia has 150 million people, andย China has aย 1.5 billion population, andย its economy is growing byย leaps andย boundsย โ over five percent aย year, it used toย be even more. But that’s enough forย China. Asย Bismark once put it, potentials are most important. China’s potential is enormousย โ it is theย biggest economy inย theย world today inย terms ofย purchasing power parity andย theย size ofย theย economy. It has already overtaken theย United States, quite aย long time ago, andย it is growing atย aย rapid clip.
Let’s not talk about who is afraid ofย whom, let’s not reason inย such terms. Andย let’s get into theย fact that after 1991, when Russia expected that it would be welcomed into theย brotherly family ofย โcivilized nations,โ nothing like this happened. You tricked us (Iย don’t mean you personally when Iย say โyouโ, ofย course, I’m talking about theย United States), theย promise was that NATO would not expand eastward, but it happened five times, there were five waves ofย expansion. We tolerated all that, we were trying toย persuade them, we were saying: โPlease don’t, we are asย bourgeois now asย you are, we are aย market economy, andย there is no Communist Party power. Let’s negotiate.โ Moreover, Iย have also said this publicly before (let’s look atย Yeltsin’s times now), there was aย moment when aย certain rift started growing between us. Before that, Yeltsin came toย theย United States, remember, he spoke inย Congress andย said theย good words: โGod bless Americaโ. Everything he said were signalsย โ let us in.
Remember theย developments inย Yugoslavia, before that Yeltsin was lavished with praise, asย soon asย theย developments inย Yugoslavia started, he raised his voice inย support ofย Serbs, andย we couldn’t but raise our voices forย Serbs inย their defense. Iย understand that there were complex processes underway there, Iย do. But Russia could not help raising its voice inย support ofย Serbs, because Serbs are also aย special andย close toย us nation, with Orthodox culture andย so on. It’s aย nation that has suffered so much forย generations. Well, regardless, what is important is that Yeltsin expressed his support. What did theย United States do? Inย violation ofย international law andย theย UN Charter it started bombing Belgrade.
It was theย United States that let theย genie out ofย theย bottle. Moreover, when Russia protested andย expressed its resentment, what was said? Theย UN Charter andย international law have become obsolete. Now everyone invokes international law, but atย that time they started saying that everything was outdated, everything had toย be changed.
Indeed, some things need toย be changed asย theย balance ofย power has changed, it’s true, but not inย this manner. Yeltsin was immediately dragged through theย mud, accused ofย alcoholism, ofย understanding nothing, ofย knowing nothing. He understood everything, Iย assure you.
Well, Iย became President inย 2000. Iย thought: okay, theย Yugoslav issue is over, but we should try toย restore relations. Let’s reopen theย door that Russia had tried toย go through. Andย moreover, I’ve said it publicly, Iย can reiterate. Atย aย meeting here inย theย Kremlin with theย outgoing President Bill Clinton, right here inย theย next room, Iย said toย him, Iย asked him, โ Bill, do you think if Russia asked toย join NATO, do you think it would happen?โ Suddenly he said: โYou know, it’s interesting, Iย think so.โ But inย theย evening, when we had dinner, he said, โYou know, I’ve talked toย myย team, no-no, it’s not possible now.โ You can ask him, Iย think he will watch our interview, he’ll confirm it. Iย wouldn’t have said anything like that if it hadn’t happened. Okay, well, it’s impossible now.
Tucker Carlson: Were you sincere? Would you have joined NATO?
Vladimir Putin: Look, Iย asked theย question, โIs it possible orย not?โ Andย theย answer Iย got was no. If Iย was insincere inย myย desire toย find out what theย leadership’s position wasโฆ
Tucker Carlson: But if he would say yes, would you have joined NATO?
Vladimir Putin: If he had said yes, theย process ofย rapprochement would have commenced, andย eventually it might have happened if we had seen some sincere wish onย theย side ofย our partners. But it didn’t happen. Well, no means no, okay, fine.
Tucker Carlson: Why do you think that is? Just toย get toย motive. Iย know, youโre clearly bitter about it. Iย understand. But why do you think theย West rebuffed you then? Why theย hostility? Why did theย end ofย theย Cold War not fix theย relationship? What motivates this from your point ofย view?
Vladimir Putin: You said Iย was bitter about theย answer. No, it’s not bitterness, it’s just aย statement ofย fact. We’re not theย bride andย groom, bitterness, resentment, it’s not about those kinds ofย matters inย such circumstances. We just realised we weren’t welcome there, that’s all. Okay, fine. But let’s build relations inย another manner, let’s look forย common ground elsewhere. Why we received such aย negative response, you should ask your leader. Iย can only guess why: too big aย country, with its own opinion andย so on. Andย theย United Statesย โ Iย have seen how issues are being resolved inย NATO.
Iย will give you another example now, concerning Ukraine. Theย US leadership exerts pressure, andย all NATO members obediently vote, even if they do not like something. Now, I’ll tell you what happened inย this regard with Ukraine inย 2008, although it’s being discussed, Iโm not going toย open aย secret toย you, say anything new. Nevertheless, after that, we tried toย build relations inย different ways. Forย example, theย events inย theย Middle East, inย Iraq, we were building relations with theย United States inย aย very soft, prudent, cautious manner.
Iย repeatedly raised theย issue that theย United States should not support separatism orย terrorism inย theย North Caucasus. But they continued toย do it anyway. Andย political support, information support, financial support, even military support came from theย United States andย its satellites forย terrorist groups inย theย Caucasus.
Iย once raised this issue with myย colleague, also theย President ofย theย United States. He says, โItโs impossible! Do you have proof?โ Iย said, โYes.โ Iย was prepared forย this conversation andย Iย gave him that proof. He looked atย it and, you know what he said? Iย apologise, but that’s what happened, I’ll quote. He says, โWell, Iโm gonna kick their assโ. We waited andย waited forย some responseย โ there was no reply.
Iย said toย theย FSB Director: โWrite toย theย CIA. What is theย result ofย theย conversation with theย President?โ He wrote once, twice, andย then we got aย reply. We have theย answer inย theย archive. Theย CIA replied: โWe have been working with theย opposition inย Russia. We believe that this is theย right thing toย do andย we will keep onย doing it.โ Just ridiculous. Well, okay. We realised that it was out ofย theย question.
Tucker Carlson: Forces inย opposition toย you? Do you think theย CIA is trying toย overthrow your government?
Vladimir Putin: Ofย course, they meant inย that particular case theย separatists, theย terrorists who fought with us inย theย Caucasus. That’s who they called theย opposition. This is theย second point.
Theย third moment, aย very important one, is theย moment when theย US missile defense (ABM) system was created. Theย beginning. We persuaded forย aย long time not toย do it inย theย United States. Moreover, after Iย was invited byย Bush Jr.’s father, Bush Sr. toย visit his place onย theย ocean, Iย had aย very serious conversation with President Bush andย his team. Iย proposed that theย United States, Russia andย Europe jointly create aย missile defense system that, we believe, if created unilaterally, threatens our security, despite theย fact that theย United States officially said that it was being created against missile threats from Iran. That was theย justification forย theย deployment ofย theย missile defense system. Iย suggested working togetherย โ Russia, theย United States, andย Europe. They said it was very interesting. They asked me, โAre you serious?โ Iย said, โAbsolutelyโ.
Tucker Carlson: May Iย ask what year was this?
Vladimir Putin: Iย don’t remember. It is easy toย find out onย theย Internet, when Iย was inย theย USA atย theย invitation ofย Bush Sr. It is even easier toย learn from someone, Iโm going toย tell you about.
Iย was told it was very interesting. Iย said, โJust imagine if we could tackle such aย global, strategic security challenge together. Theย world would change. We’ll probably have disputes, probably economic andย even political ones, but we could drastically change theย situation inย theย world.โ He says, โYes.โ Andย asks: โAre you serious?โ. Iย said, โOfย course.โ โWe need toย think about it,โ I’m told. Iย said, โGo ahead, please.โ
Then Secretary ofย Defense R.Gates, former Director ofย theย CIA, andย Secretary ofย State C.Rice came here, inย this cabinet. Right here, atย this table, they sat onย this side. Me, theย Foreign Minister, theย Russian Defense Ministerย โ onย that side. They said toย me, โYes, we have thought about it, we agree.โ Iย said, โThank God, great.โย โ โBut with some exceptions.โ
Tucker Carlson: So, twice you’ve described US presidents making decisions andย then being undercut byย their agency heads. So, it sounds like you’re describing aย system that is not run byย theย people who are elected, inย your telling.
Vladimir Putin: That’s right, that’s right. Inย theย end they just told us toย get lost. Iย am not going toย tell you theย details, because Iย think it is incorrect, after all, it was aย confidential conversation. But our proposal was declined, thatโs aย fact.
It was right then when Iย said: โLook, but then we will be forced toย take counter measures. We will create such strike systems that will certainly overcome missile defense systems.โ Theย answer was: โWe are not doing this against you, andย you do what you want, assuming that it is not against us, not against theย United Statesโ. Iย said, โOkay.โ
Very well, thatโs theย way it went. Andย we created hypersonic systems, with intercontinental range, andย we continue toย develop them. We are now ahead ofย everyoneย โ theย United States andย other countriesย โ inย terms ofย theย development ofย hypersonic strike systems, andย we are improving them every day.
But it wasnโt us, we proposed toย go theย other way, andย we were pushed back.
Now, about NATO’s expansion toย theย East. Well, we were promised, no NATO toย theย East, not anย inch toย theย East, asย we were told. Andย then what? They said, โWell, it’s not enshrined onย paper, so we’ll expand.โ So there were five waves ofย expansion, theย Baltic States, theย whole ofย Eastern Europe, andย so on.
Andย now Iย come toย theย main thing: they have come toย Ukraine ultimately. Inย 2008 atย theย summit inย Bucharest they declared that theย doors forย Ukraine andย Georgia toย join NATO were open.
Now about how decisions are made there. Germany, France seemed toย be against it asย well asย some other European countries. But then, asย it turned out later, President Bush, andย he is such aย tough guy, aย tough politician, asย Iย was told later, โHe exerted pressure onย us andย we had toย agree.โ It’s ridiculous, it’s like kindergarten. Where are theย guarantees? What kindergarten is this, what kind ofย people are these, who are they? You see, they were pressed, they agreed. Andย then they say, โUkraine won’t be inย NATO, you know.โ Iย say, โIย don’t know, Iย know you agreed inย 2008, why won’t you agree inย theย future?โ โWell, they pressed us then.โ Iย say, โWhy won’t they press you tomorrow? Andย you’ll agree again.โ
Well, it’s nonsensical. Who’s there toย talk to, Iย just don’t understand. We’re ready toย talk. But with whom? Where are theย guarantees? None.
So, they started toย develop theย territory ofย Ukraine. Whatever is there, Iย have told you theย background, how this territory developed, what kind ofย relations there were with Russia. Every second orย third person there has always had some ties with Russia. Andย during theย elections inย already independent, sovereign Ukraine, which gained its independence asย aย result ofย theย Declaration ofย Independence, and, byย theย way, it says that Ukraine is aย neutral state, andย inย 2008 suddenly theย doors orย gates toย NATO were open toย it. Oh, come on! This is not how we agreed. Now, all theย presidents that have come toย power inย Ukraine, they’ve relied onย anย electorate with aย good attitude toย Russia inย one way orย another. This is theย south-east ofย Ukraine, this is aย large number ofย people. Andย it was very difficult toย desuade this electorate, which had aย positive attitude towards Russia.
Viktor Yanukovych came toย power, andย how: theย first time he won after President Kuchmaย โ they organised aย third round, which is not provided forย inย theย Constitution ofย Ukraine. This is aย coup d’รฉtat. Just imagine, someone inย theย United States wouldnโt like theย outcomeโฆ
Tucker Carlson: Inย 2014?
Vladimir Putin: Before that. No, this was before that. After President Kuchma, Viktor Yanukovich won theย elections. However, his opponents did not recognize that victory, theย US supported theย opposition andย theย third round was scheduled. What is this? This is aย coup. Theย US supported it andย theย winner ofย theย third round came toย power. Imagine if inย theย US, something was not toย someoneโs liking andย theย third round ofย election, which theย US Constitution does not provide for, was organized, Nonetheless, it was done inย Ukraine. Okay, Viktor Yushchenko who was considered aย pro-Western politician, came toย power. Fine, we have built relations with him asย well. He came toย Moscow with visits, we visited Kiev. Iย visited it too. We met inย anย informal setting. If he is pro-Western, so be it. Itโs fine, let people do their job. Theย situation should develop inside theย independent Ukraine itself. Asย aย result ofย Kuchmaโs leadership, things got worse andย Viktor Yanukovich came toย power after all.
Maybe he wasnโt theย best President andย politician. Iย donโt know, Iย donโt want toย give assessments. However, theย issue ofย theย association with theย EU came up. We have always been lenient toย this: suit yourself. But when we read through that treaty ofย association it turned out toย be aย problem forย us, since we had aย free-trade zone andย open customs borders with Ukraine which, under this association, had toย open its borders forย Europe, which could have led toย flooding ofย our market.
We said, โNo, this is not going toย work. We shall close our borders with Ukraine thenโ. Theย customs borders, that is. Yanukovich started toย calculate how much Ukraine was going toย gain, how much toย lose andย said toย his European partners: โIย need more time toย think before signingโ. Theย moment he said that, theย opposition began toย take destructive steps which were supported byย theย West. It all came down toย Maidan andย aย coup inย Ukraine.
Tucker Carlson: So, he did more trade with Russia than with theย EU? Ukraine didโฆ
Vladimir Putin: Ofย course. Itโs not even theย matter ofย trade volume, although forย theย most part it is. It is theย matter ofย cooperation ties which theย entire Ukrainian economy was based on. Theย cooperation ties between theย enterprises were very close since theย times ofย theย Soviet Union. One enterprise there used toย produce components toย be assembled both inย Russia andย Ukraine andย vice versa. There used toย be very close ties.
Aย coup dโetat was committed, although, Iย shall not delve into details now asย Iย find doing it inappropriate, theย US told us, โCalm Yanukovich down andย we will calm theย opposition. Let theย situation unfold inย theย scenario ofย aย political settlementโ. We said, โAlright. Agreed. Letโs do it this wayโ. Asย theย Americans requested us, Yanukovich did use neither theย Armed Forces, nor theย police, yet theย armed opposition committed aย coup inย Kiev. What is that supposed toย mean? โWho do you think you are?โ, Iย wanted toย ask theย then US leadership.
Tucker Carlson: With theย backing ofย whom?
Vladimir Putin: With theย backing ofย CIA, ofย course. Theย organization you wanted toย join back inย theย day, asย Iย understand. Maybe we should thank God they didnโt let you in. Although, it is aย serious organization. Iย understand. Myย former vis-ร -vis, inย theย sense that Iย served inย theย First Main Directorateย โ Soviet Unionโs intelligence service. They have always been our opponents. Aย job is aย job.
Technically they did everything right, they achieved their goal ofย changing theย government. However, from political standpoint, it was aย colossal mistake. Surely, it was political leadershipโs miscalculation. They should have seen what it would evolve into.
So, inย 2008 theย doors ofย NATO were opened forย Ukraine. Inย 2014, there was aย coup, they started persecuting those who did not accept theย coup, andย it was indeed aย coup, they created aย threat toย Crimea which we had toย take under our protection. They launched aย war inย Donbass inย 2014 with theย use ofย aircraft andย artillery against civilians. This is when it started. There is aย video ofย aircraft attacking Donetsk from above. They launched aย large-scale military operation, then another one. When they failed, they started toย prepare theย next one. All this against theย background ofย military development ofย this territory andย opening ofย NATOโs doors.
How could we not express concern over what was happening? From our side, this would have been aย culpable negligenceย โ thatโs what it would have been. Itโs just that theย US political leadership pushed us toย theย line we could not cross because doing so could have ruined Russia itself. Besides, we could not leave our brothers inย faith and, inย fact, aย part ofย Russian people, inย theย face ofย this โwar machineโ.
Tucker Carlson: So, that was eight years before theย current conflict started. What was theย trigger forย you? What was theย moment where you decided you had toย do this?
Vladimir Putin: Initially, it was theย coup inย Ukraine that provoked theย conflict.
Byย theย way, back then theย representatives ofย three European countriesย โ Germany, Poland andย Franceย โ arrived. They were theย guarantors ofย theย signed agreement between theย Government ofย Yanukovich andย theย opposition. They signed it asย guarantors. Despite that, theย opposition committed aย coup andย all these countries pretended that they didnโt remember that they were guarantors ofย peaceful settlement. They just threw it inย theย stove right away andย nobody recalls that.
Iย donโt know if theย US know anything about that agreement between theย opposition andย theย authorities andย its three guarantors who, instead ofย bringing this whole situation back inย theย political field, supported theย coup. Although, it was meaningless, believe me, because President Yanukovich agreed toย all conditions, he was ready toย hold early election which he had no chance toย win, frankly speaking, Everyone knew that. Then why theย coup, why theย victims? Why threatening Crimea? Why launching anย operation inย Donbass? This Iย do not understand. That is exactly what theย miscalculation is. CIA did its job toย complete theย coup. Iย think one ofย theย Deputy Secretaries ofย State said that it cost aย large sum ofย money, almost 5 billion. But theย political mistake was colossal! Why would they have toย do that? All this could have been done legally, without victims, without military action, without losing Crimea. We would have never considered toย even lift aย finger, if it hadnโt been forย theย bloody developments onย Maidan.
Because we agreed with theย fact that after theย collapse ofย theย Soviet Union our borders should be along theย borders ofย former Unionโs republics. We agreed toย that. But we never agreed toย NATOโs expansion andย moreover we never agreed that Ukraine would be inย NATO. We did not agree toย NATO bases there without any discussion with us. Forย decades we kept asking: donโt do this, donโt do that.
Andย what triggered theย latest events? Firstly, theย current Ukrainian leadership declared that it would not implement theย Minsk Agreements, which had been signed, asย you know, after theย events ofย 2014, inย Minsk, where theย plan ofย peaceful settlement inย Donbass was set forth. But no, theย current Ukrainian leadership, Foreign Minister, all other officials andย then President himself said that they donโt like anything about theย Minsk Agreements. Inย other words, they were not going toย implement it. Aย year orย aย year andย aย half ago, former leaders ofย Germany andย France said openly toย theย whole world that they indeed signed theย Minsk Agreements but they never intended toย implement them. They simply led us byย theย nose.
Tucker Carlson: Was there anyone free toย talk to? Did you call theย US President, Secretary ofย State andย say if you keep militarizing Ukraine with NATO forces, we are going toย act?
Vladimir Putin: We talked about this all theย time. We addressed theย United Statesโ andย European countriesโ leadership toย stop these developments immediately, toย implement theย Minsk Agreements. Frankly speaking, Iย didnโt know how we were going toย do this but Iย was ready toย implement them. These Agreements were complicated forย Ukraine; they included lots ofย elements ofย those Donbass territoriesโ independence. Thatโs true. However, Iย was absolutely confident, andย Iย am saying this toย you now: Iย honestly believed that if we managed toย convince theย residents ofย Donbassย โ andย we had toย work hard toย convince them toย return toย theย Ukrainian statehoodย โ then gradually theย wounds would start toย heal. When this part ofย territory reintegrated itself into common social environment, when theย pensions andย social benefits were paid again, all theย pieces would gradually fall into place.
No, nobody wanted that, everybody wanted toย resolve theย issue byย military force only. But we could not let that happen. Andย theย situation got toย theย point, when theย Ukrainian side announced: โNo, we will not do anythingโ. They also started preparing forย military action. It was they who started theย war inย 2014. Our goal is toย stop this war. Andย we did not start this war inย 2022. This is anย attempt toย stop it.
Tucker Carlson: Do you think you have stopped it now? Iย mean have you achieved your aims?
Vladimir Putin: No, we haven’t achieved our aims yet, because one ofย them is denazification. This means theย prohibition ofย all kinds ofย neo-Nazi movements. This is one ofย theย problems that we discussed during theย negotiation process, which ended inย Istanbul early last year, andย it was not our initiative, because we were told (byย theย Europeans, inย particular) that โit was necessary toย create conditions forย theย final signing ofย theย documentsโ. Myย counterparts inย France andย Germany said, โHow can you imagine them signing aย treaty with aย gun toย their heads? Theย troops should be pulled back from Kiev. โIย said, โAll right.โ We withdrew theย troops from Kiev.
Asย soon asย we pulled back our troops from Kiev, our Ukrainian negotiators immediately threw all our agreements reached inย Istanbul into theย bin andย got prepared forย aย longstanding armed confrontation with theย help ofย theย United States andย its satellites inย Europe. That is how theย situation has developed. Andย that is how it looks now.
Tucker Carlson: What is denazification? What would that mean?
Vladimir Putin: That is what Iย want toย talk about right now. It is aย very important issue.
Denazification. After gaining independence, Ukraine began toย search, asย some Western analysts say, its identity. Andย it came up with nothing better than toย build this identity upon some false heroes who collaborated with Hitler.
Iย have already said that inย theย early 19th century, when theย theorists ofย independence andย sovereignty ofย Ukraine appeared, they assumed that anย independent Ukraine should have very good relations with Russia. But due toย theย historical development, these territories were part ofย theย Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealthย โ Poland, where Ukrainians were persecuted andย treated quite brutally asย well asย were subject toย cruel behavior. There were also attempts toย destroy their identity. All this remained inย theย memory ofย theย people. When World War II broke out, part ofย this extremely nationalist elite collaborated with Hitler, believing that he would bring them freedom. Theย German troops, even theย SS troops made Hitler’s collaborators do theย dirtiest work ofย exterminating theย Polish andย Jewish population. Hence this brutal massacre ofย theย Polish andย Jewish population asย well asย theย Russian population too. This was led byย theย persons who are well knownย โ Bandera, Shukhevich. It was these people who were made national heroesย โ that is theย problem. Andย we are constantly told that nationalism andย neo-Nazism exist inย other countries asย well. Yes, there are seedlings, but we uproot them, andย other countries fight against them. But Ukraine is not theย case. These people have been made into national heroes inย Ukraine. Monuments toย these people have been erected, they are displayed onย flags, their names are shouted byย crowds that walk with torches, asย it was inย Nazi Germany. These were theย people who exterminated Poles, Jews andย Russians. It is necessary toย stop this practice andย prevent theย dissemination ofย this concept.
Iย say that Ukrainians are part ofย theย one Russian people. They say, โNo, we are aย separate people.โ Okay, fine. If they consider themselves aย separate people, they have theย right toย do so, but not onย theย basis ofย Nazism, theย Nazi ideology.
Tucker Carlson: Would you be satisfied with theย territory that you have now?
Vladimir Putin: Iย will finish answering theย question. You just asked aย question about neo-Nazism andย denazification.
Look, theย President ofย Ukraine visited Canada. This story is well known, but is silenced inย theย Western countries: Theย Canadian parliament introduced aย man who, asย theย speaker ofย theย parliament said, fought against theย Russians during theย World War II. Well, who fought against theย Russians during World War II? Hitler andย his accomplices. It turned out that this man served inย theย SS troops. He personally killed Russians, Poles, andย Jews. Theย SS troops consisted ofย Ukrainian nationalists who did this dirty work. Theย President ofย Ukraine stood up with theย entire Parliament ofย Canada andย applauded this man. How can this be imagined? Theย President ofย Ukraine himself, byย theย way, is aย Jew byย nationality.
Tucker Carlson: Really, myย question is: What do you do about it? Iย mean, Hitler has been dead forย eighty years, Nazi Germany no longer exists, andย itโs true. So, Iย think, what you are saying, you want toย extinguish orย atย least control Ukrainian nationalism. But how do you do that?
Vladimir Putin: Listen toย me. Your question is very subtle.
Andย can Iย tell you what Iย think? Do not take offense.
Tucker Carlson: Ofย course!
Vladimir Putin: This question appears toย be subtle, it is quite pesky.
You say Hitler has been dead forย so many years, 80 years. But his example lives on. People who exterminated Jews, Russians andย Poles are alive. Andย theย president, theย current president ofย today’s Ukraine applauds him inย theย Canadian Parliament, gives aย standing ovation! Can we say that we have completely uprooted this ideology if what we see is happening today? That is what denazification is inย our understanding. We have toย get rid ofย those people who maintain this concept andย support this practice andย try toย preserve itย โ that is what denazification is. That is what we mean.
Tucker Carlson: Right. Myย question is almost specific, it was, ofย course, not aย defense ofย Nazism. Otherwise, it was aย practical question. You don’t control theย entire country, you donโt seem like you want to. So, how do you eliminate that culture, orย anย ideology, orย feelings, orย aย view ofย history, inย aย country that you donโt control? What do you do about that?
Vladimir Putin: You know, asย strange asย it may seem toย you, during theย negotiations inย Istanbul we did agree thatย โ we have it all inย writingย โ neo-Nazism would not be cultivated inย Ukraine, including that it would be prohibited atย theย legislative level.
Mr. Carlson, we agreed onย that. This, it turns out, can be done during theย negotiation process. Andย there is nothing humiliating forย Ukraine asย aย modern civilized State. Is any state allowed toย promote Nazism? It is not, is it? That is it.
Tucker Carlson: Will there be talks? Andย why havenโt there been talks about resolving theย conflict inย Ukraine? Peace talks.
Vladimir Putin: They have been. They reached aย very high stage ofย coordination ofย positions inย aย complex process, but still they were almost finalized. But after we withdrew our troops from Kiev, asย Iย have already said, theย other side (Ukraine) threw away all these agreements andย obeyed theย instructions ofย Western countries, European countries andย theย United States toย fight Russia toย theย bitter end.
Moreover, theย President ofย Ukraine has legislated aย ban onย negotiating with Russia. He signed aย decree forbidding everyone toย negotiate with Russia. But how are we going toย negotiate if he forbade himself andย everyone toย do this? We know that he is putting forward some ideas about this settlement. But inย order toย agree onย something, we need toย have aย dialog. Is not that right?
Tucker Carlson: Well, but you would not be speaking toย theย Ukrainian president, you would be speaking toย theย American president. When was theย last time you spoke toย Joe Biden?
Vladimir Putin: Iย cannot remember when Iย talked toย him. Iย do not remember, we can look it up.
Tucker Carlson: You do not remember?!
Vladimir Putin: No, why? Do Iย have toย remember everything? Iย have myย own things toย do. We have domestic political affairs.
Tucker Carlson: But he is funding theย war that you are fighting, so Iย think that would be memorable?
Vladimir Putin: Well, yes, he funds, but Iย talked toย him before theย Special Military Operation, ofย course. Andย Iย said toย him then, byย theย wayย โ Iย will not go into details, Iย never doย โ but Iย said toย him then: โIย believe that you are making aย huge mistake ofย historic proportions byย supporting everything that is happening there, inย Ukraine, byย pushing Russia away.โ Iย told him, told him repeatedly, byย theย way. Iย think that would be correct if Iย stop here.
Tucker Carlson: What did he say?
Vladimir Putin:ย Ask him, please. It is easier forย you, you are aย citizen ofย theย United States, go andย ask him. It is not appropriate forย me toย comment onย our conversation.
Tucker Carlson:ย But you havenโt spoken toย him since before February ofย 2022?
Vladimir Putin:ย No, we haven’t spoken. Certain contacts are been maintained though. Speaking ofย which, do you remember what Iย told you about myย proposal toย work together onย aย missile defense system?
Tucker Carlson:ย Yes.
Vladimir Putin:ย You can ask all ofย them. All ofย them are safe andย sound, thank God. Theย former President, Condoleezza is safe andย sound, and, Iย think, Mr. Gates, andย theย current Director ofย theย Central Intelligence Agency, Mr. Burns, theย then Ambassador toย Russia, inย myย opinion, aย very successful Ambassador. They were all witnesses toย these conversations. Ask them.
Same here, if you are interested inย what Mr. President Biden responded toย me, ask him. Atย any rate, Iย talked toย him about it.
Tucker Carlson:ย Iย am definitely interested. But from theย other side it seems like it could devolve, evolve into something that brings theย entire world into conflict, andย could initiate aย nuclear launch, andย so why donโt you just call Biden andย say โletโs work this outโ?
Vladimir Putin:ย What’s there toย work out? It’s very simple. Iย repeat, we have contacts through various agencies. Iย will tell you what we are saying onย this matter andย what we are conveying toย theย US leadership: โIf you really want toย stop fighting, you need toย stop supplying weapons. It will be over within aย few weeks. That’s it. Andย then we can agree onย some terms before you do that, stop.โ
What’s easier? Why would Iย call him? What should Iย talk toย him about? Orย beg him forย what? โYou’re going toย deliver such andย such weapons toย Ukraine. Oh, I’m afraid, I’m afraid, please don’t.โ What is there toย talk about?
Tucker Carlson:ย Do you think NATO was worried about this becoming aย global war orย nuclear conflict?
Vladimir Putin:ย Atย least that’s what they’re talking about. Andย they are trying toย intimidate their own population with anย imaginary Russian threat. This is anย obvious fact. Andย thinking people, not philistines, but thinking people, analysts, those who are engaged inย real politics, just smart people understand perfectly well that this is aย fake. They are trying toย fuel theย Russian threat.
Tucker Carlson:ย Theย threat Iย think you were referring toย is Russian invasion ofย Poland, Latviaย โ expansionist behavior. Can you imagine aย scenario where you send Russian troops toย Poland?
Vladimir Putin:ย Only inย one case: if Poland attacks Russia. Why? Because we have no interest inย Poland, Latvia orย anywhere else. Why would we do that? We simply don’t have any interest. Its just threat mongering.
Tucker Carlson:ย Well, theย argument, Iย know you know this, is that, well, he invaded Ukraineย โ he has territorial aims across theย continent. Andย you are saying unequivocally, you donโt?
Vladimir Putin:ย It is absolutely out ofย theย question. You just don’t have toย be any kind ofย analyst, it goes against common sense toย get involved inย some kind ofย global war. Andย aย global war will bring all ofย humanity toย theย brink ofย destruction. It’s obvious.
There are, certainly, means ofย deterrence. They have been scaring everyone with us all along: tomorrow Russia will use tactical nuclear weapons, tomorrow Russia will use that, no, theย day after tomorrow. So what? These are just horror stories forย people inย theย street inย order toย extort additional money from US taxpayers andย European taxpayers inย theย confrontation with Russia inย theย Ukrainian theatre ofย war. Theย goal is toย weaken Russia asย much asย possible.
Tucker Carlson:ย One ofย our senior United States senators from theย State ofย New York, Chuck Schumer, said yesterday, Iย believe, that we have toย continue toย fund theย Ukrainian effort orย US soldiers, citizens could wind up fighting there. How do you assess that?
Vladimir Putin:ย This is aย provocation, andย aย cheap provocation atย that.
Iย do not understand why American soldiers should fight inย Ukraine. There are mercenaries from theย United States there. Theย biggest number ofย mercenaries comes from Poland, with mercenaries from theย United States inย second place, andย mercenaries from Georgia inย third place. Well, if somebody has theย desire toย send regular troops, that would certainly bring humanity onย theย brink ofย aย very serious, global conflict. This is obvious.
Do theย United States need this? What for? Thousands ofย miles away from your national territory! Don’t you have anything better toย do?
You have issues onย theย border, issues with migration, issues with theย national debtย โ more than 33 trillion dollars. You have nothing better toย do, so you should fight inย Ukraine? Wouldn’t it be better toย negotiate with Russia? Make anย agreement, already understanding theย situation that is developing today, realizing that Russia will fight forย its interests toย theย end. And, realizing this, actually return toย common sense, start respecting our country andย its interests andย look forย certain solutions. It seems toย me that this is much smarter andย more rational.
Tucker Carlson:ย Who blew up Nord Stream?
Vladimir Putin:ย You, forย sure. (L aย u g h iย n g.)
Tucker Carlson:ย Iย was busy that day. Iย did not blow up Nord Stream.
Vladimir Putin:ย You personally may have anย alibi, but theย CIA has no such alibi.
Tucker Carlson:ย Do you have evidence that NATO orย CIA did it?
Vladimir Putin:ย You know, Iย won’t get into details, but people always say inย such cases: โLook forย someone who is interestedโ. But inย this case we should not only look forย someone who is interested, but also forย someone who has capabilities. Because there may be many people interested, but not all ofย them are capable ofย sinking toย theย bottom ofย theย Baltic Sea andย carrying out this explosion. These two components should be connected: who is interested andย who is capable ofย doing it.
Tucker Carlson:ย But Iย am confused. Iย mean, thatโs theย biggest act ofย industrial terrorism ever andย itโs theย largest emission ofย COโ inย history. Okay, so, if you had evidence andย presumably, given your security services, your intel services, you would, that NATO, theย US, CIA, theย West did this, why wouldnโt you present it andย win aย propaganda victory?
Vladimir Putin:ย Inย theย war ofย propaganda it is very difficult toย defeat theย United States because theย United States controls all theย worldโs media andย many European media. Theย ultimate beneficiary ofย theย biggest European media are American financial institutions. Don’t you know that? So it is possible toย get involved inย this work, but it is cost prohibitive, so toย speak. We can simply shine theย spotlight onย our sources ofย information, andย we will not achieve results. It is clear toย theย whole world what happened, andย even American analysts talk about it directly. It’s true.
Tucker Carlson:ย Yes. But here is aย question you may be able toย answer. You worked inย Germany, famously. Theย Germans clearly know that their NATO partner did this, that they damaged their economy greatlyย โ it may never recover. Why are they being silent about it? That is very confusing toย me. Why wouldnโt theย Germans say something about it?
Vladimir Putin:ย This also confuses me. But today’s German leadership is guided byย theย interests ofย theย collective West rather than its national interests, otherwise it is difficult toย explain theย logic ofย their action orย inaction. After all, it is not only about Nord Stream-1, which was blown up, andย Nord Stream-2 was damaged, but one pipe is safe andย sound, andย gas can be supplied toย Europe through it, but Germany does not open it. We are ready, please.
There is another route through Poland, called Yamal-Europe, which also allows forย aย large flow. Poland has closed it, but Poland pecks from theย German hand, it receives money from pan-European funds, andย Germany is theย main donor toย these pan-European funds. Germany feeds Poland toย aย certain extent. Andย they closed theย route toย Germany. Why? Iย don’t understand. Ukraine, toย which theย Germans supply weapons andย give money.
Germany is theย second sponsor after theย United States inย terms ofย financial aid toย Ukraine. There are two gas routes through Ukraine. They simply closed one route, theย Ukrainians. Open theย second route and, please, get gas from Russia. They do not open it. Why don’t theย Germans say: โLook, guys, we give you money andย weapons. Open up theย valve, please, let theย gas from Russia pass through forย us.
We are buying liquefied gas atย exorbitant prices inย Europe, which brings theย level ofย our competitiveness, andย economy inย general down toย zero. Do you want us toย give you money? Let us have aย decent existence, make money forย our economy, because this is where theย money we give you comes fromโ. They refuse toย do so. Why? Ask them. (Knocks onย theย table.) That is what it is like inย their heads. Those are highly incompetent people.
Tucker Carlson:ย Well, maybe theย world is breaking into two hemispheres. One with cheap energy, theย other without it. Andย Iย want toย ask you that, if we are now aย multipolar world, obviously we are, can you describe theย blocs ofย alliances? Who is inย each side, do you think?
Vladimir Putin:ย Listen, you have said that theย world is breaking into two hemispheres. Aย human brain is divided into two hemispheres: one is responsible forย one type ofย activities, theย other one is more about creativity andย so on. But it is still one andย theย same head. Theย world should be aย single whole, security should be shared, rather than meant forย theย โgolden billionโ. That is theย only scenario where theย world could be stable, sustainable andย predictable. Until then, while theย head is split into two parts, it is anย illness, aย serious adverse condition. It is aย period ofย aย severe disease that theย world is now going through.
But Iย think that, thanks toย honest journalismย โ this work is akin toย work ofย theย doctors, this could somehow be remedied.
Tucker Carlson:ย Well, letโs just give one exampleย โ theย US dollar, which has, kind of, united theย world inย aย lot ofย ways, maybe not toย your advantage, but certainly toย ours. Is that going away asย theย reserve currency, theย universally accepted currency? How have sanctions, do you think, changed theย dollarโs place inย theย world?
Vladimir Putin:ย You know, toย use theย dollar asย aย tool ofย foreign policy struggle is one ofย theย biggest strategic mistakes made byย theย US political leadership. Theย dollar is theย cornerstone ofย theย United States’ power. Iย think everyone understands very well that, no matter how many dollars are printed, they are quickly dispersed all over theย world. Inflation inย theย United States is minimal. It is about 3 orย 3.4ย per cent, which is, Iย think, totally acceptable forย theย US. But they won’t stop printing. What does theย debt ofย 33 trillion dollars tell us about? It is about theย emission.
Nevertheless, it is theย main weapon used byย theย United States toย preserve its power across theย world. Asย soon asย theย political leadership decided toย use theย US dollar asย aย tool ofย political struggle, aย blow was dealt toย this American power. Iย would not like toย use any strong language, but it is aย stupid thing toย do, andย aย grave mistake.
Look atย what is going onย inย theย world. Even theย United States’ allies are now downsizing their dollar reserves. Seeing this, everyone starts looking forย ways toย protect themselves. But theย fact that theย United States applies restrictive measures toย certain countries, such asย placing restrictions onย transactions, freezing assets, etc., causes grave concern andย sends aย signal toย theย whole world.
What did we have here? Until 2022, about 80ย per cent ofย Russia’s foreign trade transactions were made inย US dollars andย euros. US dollars accounted forย approximately 50 per cent ofย our transactions with third countries, while currently it is down toย 13 per cent. It was not us who banned theย use ofย theย US dollar, we had no such intention. It was theย decision ofย theย United States toย restrict our transactions inย US dollars. Iย think it is aย complete foolishness from theย point ofย view ofย theย interests ofย theย United States itself andย its tax payers, asย it damages theย US economy, undermines theย power ofย theย United States across theย world.
Byย theย way, our transactions inย Yuan accounted forย about 3 per cent. Today, 34 per cent ofย our transactions are made inย Rubles, andย about asย much, aย little over 34 per cent, inย Yuan.
Why did theย United States do this? Myย only guess is self-conceit. They probably thought it would lead toย aย full collapse, but nothing collapsed. Moreover, other countries, including oil producers, are thinking ofย andย already accepting payments forย oil inย yuan. Do you even realize what is going onย orย not? Does anyone inย theย United States realize this? What are you doing? You are cutting yourself offโฆ all experts say this. Ask any intelligent andย thinking person inย theย United States what theย dollar means forย theย US? You are killing it with your own hands.
Tucker Carlson:ย Iย think that is aย fair assessment. Theย question is what comes next? Andย maybe you trade one colonial power forย another, much less sentimental andย forgiving colonial power? Is theย BRICS, forย example, inย danger ofย being completely dominated byย theย Chinese economy? Inย aย way that is not good forย their sovereignty. Do you worry about that?
Vladimir Putin:ย We have heard those boogeyman stories before. It is aย boogeyman story. We are neighbours with China. You cannot choose neighbours, just asย you cannot choose close relatives. We share aย border ofย 1000 kilometers with them. This is number one.
Second, we have aย centuries-long history ofย coexistence, we are used toย it.
Third, China’s foreign policy philosophy is not aggressive, its idea is toย always look forย compromise, andย we can see that.
Theย next point is asย follows. We are always told theย same boogeyman story, andย here it goes again, though inย aย euphemistic form, but it is still theย same bogeyman story: theย cooperation with China keeps increasing. Theย pace atย which China’s cooperation with Europe is growing is higher andย greater than that ofย theย growth ofย Chinese-Russian cooperation. Ask Europeans: arenโt they afraid? They might be, Iย do not know, but they are still trying toย access China’s market atย all costs, especially now that they are facing economic problems. Chinese businesses are also exploring theย European market.
Do Chinese businesses have small presence inย theย United States? Yes, theย political decisions are such that they are trying toย limit their cooperation with China.
It is toย your own detriment, Mr Tucker, that you are limiting cooperation with China, you are hurting yourself. It is aย delicate matter, andย there are no silver bullet solutions, just asย it is with theย dollar.
So, before introducing any illegitimate sanctionsย โ illegitimate inย terms ofย theย Charter ofย theย United Nationsย โ one should think very carefully. Forย decision-makers, this appears toย be aย problem.
Tucker Carlson:ย So, you said aย moment ago that theย world would be aย lot better if it were not broken into competing alliances, if there was cooperation globally. One ofย theย reasons you donโt have that is because theย current American administration is dead set against you. Do you think if there was aย new administration after Joe Biden that you would be able toย re-establish communication with theย US government? Orย does it not matter who theย President is?
Vladimir Putin:ย Iย will tell you. But let me finish theย previous thought. We, together with myย colleague andย friend President Xi Jinping, set aย goal toย reach 200 billion dollars ofย mutual trade with China this year. We have exceeded this level. According toย our figures, our bilateral trade with China totals already 230 billion, andย theย Chinese statistics says it is 240 billion dollars.
One more important thing: our trade is well-balanced, mutually complementary inย high-tech, energy, scientific research andย development. It is very balanced.
Asย forย BRICS, where Russia took over theย presidency this year, theย BRICS countries are, byย andย large, developing very rapidly.
Look, if memory serves me right, back inย 1992, theย share ofย theย G7 countries inย theย world economy amounted toย 47 per cent, whereas inย 2022 it was down to, Iย think, aย little over 30 per cent. Theย BRICS countries accounted forย only 16 per cent inย 1992, but now their share is greater than that ofย theย G7. It has nothing toย do with theย events inย Ukraine. This is due toย theย trends ofย global development andย world economy that Iย mentioned just now, andย this is inevitable. This will keep happening, it is like theย rise ofย theย sunย โ you cannot prevent theย sun from rising, you have toย adapt toย it. How do theย United States adapt? With theย help ofย force: sanctions, pressure, bombings, andย use ofย armed forces.
This is about self-conceit. Your political establishment does not understand that theย world is changing (under objective circumstances), andย inย order toย preserve your levelย โ even if someone aspires, pardon me, toย theย level ofย dominanceย โ you have toย make theย right decisions inย aย competent andย timely manner.
Such brutal actions, including with regard toย Russia and, say, other countries, are counterproductive. This is anย obvious fact; it has already become evident.
You just asked me if another leader comes andย changes something. It is not about theย leader, it is not about theย personality ofย aย particular person. Iย had aย very good relationship with, say, Bush. Iย know that inย theย United States he was portrayed asย some kind ofย aย country boy who does not understand much. Iย assure you that is not theย case. Iย think he made aย lot ofย mistakes with regard toย Russia, too. Iย told you about 2008 andย theย decision inย Bucharest toย open theย NATOโs doors toย forย Ukraine andย so on. That happened during his presidency. He actually exercised pressure onย theย Europeans.
But inย general, onย aย personal human level, Iย had aย very good relationship with him. He was no worse than any other American, orย Russian, orย European politician. Iย assure you, he understood what he was doing asย well asย others. Iย had such personal relationships with Trump asย well.
It is not about theย personality ofย theย leader, it is about theย elitesโ mindset. If theย idea ofย domination atย any cost, based also onย forceful actions, dominates theย American society, nothing will change, it will only get worse. But if, inย theย end, one comes toย theย awareness that theย world has been changing due toย objective circumstances, andย that one should be able toย adapt toย them inย time, using theย advantages that theย U.S. still has today, then, perhaps, something may change.
Look, China’s economy has become theย first economy inย theย world inย purchasing power parity; inย terms ofย volume it overtook theย US aย long time ago. Theย USA comes second, then India (one andย aย half billion people), andย then Japan, with Russia inย theย fifth place. Russia was theย first economy inย Europe last year, despite all theย sanctions andย restrictions. Is this normal, from your point ofย view: sanctions, restrictions, impossibility ofย payments inย dollars, being cut off from SWIFT services, sanctions against our ships carrying oil, sanctions against airplanes, sanctions inย everything, everywhere? Theย largest number ofย sanctions inย theย world which are appliedย โ are applied against Russia. Andย we have become Europe’s first economy during this time.
Theย tools that theย US uses don’t work. Well, one has toย think about what toย do. If this realization comes toย theย ruling elites, then yes, then theย first person ofย theย state will act inย anticipation ofย what theย voters andย theย people who make decisions atย various levels expect from this person. Then maybe something will change.
Tucker Carlson:ย But you are describing two different systems. You say that theย leader acts inย theย interests ofย theย voters, but you also say that these decisions are not made byย theย leaderย โ they are made byย theย ruling classes. You have run this country forย so long, you have known all these American presidents. What are those power centers inย theย United States, do you think? Andย who actually makes theย decisions?
Vladimir Putin:ย Iย don’t know. America is aย complex country, conservative onย theย one hand, rapidly changing onย theย other. It’s not easy forย us toย sort it all out.
Who makes decisions inย theย electionsย โ is it possible toย understand this, when each state has its own legislation, each state regulates itself, someone can be excluded from theย elections atย theย state level. It is aย two-stage electoral system, it is very difficult forย us toย understand it.
Certainly there are two parties that are dominant, theย Republicans andย theย Democrats, andย within this party system, theย centers that make decisions, that prepare decisions.
Then, look, why, inย myย opinion, after theย collapse ofย theย Soviet Union, such anย erroneous, crude, completely unjustified policy ofย pressure was pursued against Russia? After all, this is aย policy ofย pressure. NATO expansion, support forย theย separatists inย theย Caucasus, creation ofย aย missile defense systemย โ these are all elements ofย pressure. Pressure, pressure, pressure.
Then, dragging Ukraine into NATO is all about pressure, pressure, pressure. Why? Iย think, among other things, because excessive production capacities were created. During theย confrontation with theย Soviet Union, there were many centers created andย specialists onย theย Soviet Union, who could not do anything else. It seemed toย them, they convinced theย political leadership: it is necessary toย continue โchiselingโ Russia, toย try toย break it up, toย create onย this territory several quasi-state entities andย toย subdue them inย aย divided form, toย use their combined potential forย theย future struggle with China. This is aย mistake, including theย excessive potential ofย those who worked forย theย confrontation with theย Soviet Union. It is necessary toย get rid ofย this, there should be new, fresh forces, people who look into theย future andย understand what is happening inย theย world.
Look atย how Indonesia is developing? 600 million people. Where can we get away from that? Nowhere, we just have toย assume that Indonesia will enter (it is already in) theย club ofย theย world’s leading economies, no matter who likes orย dislikes it.
Yes, we understand andย are aware that inย theย United States, despite all theย economic problems, theย situation is still normal with theย economy growing decently, theย GDP is growing byย 2.5 percent, if Iย am not mistaken.
But if we want toย ensure theย future, then we need toย change our approach toย what is changing. Asย Iย already said, theย world would nevertheless change regardless ofย how theย developments inย Ukraine end. Theย world is changing. Inย theย United States themselves, experts write that theย United States are nonetheless gradually changing their position inย theย world, it is your experts who write that, Iย just read them. Theย only question is how this would happenย โ painfully andย quickly orย gently andย gradually. Andย this is written byย people who are not anti-American; they simply follow global development trends. That’s it.
Andย inย order toย assess them andย change policies, we need people who think, look forward, can analyze andย recommend certain decisions atย theย level ofย political leaders.
Tucker Carlson: Iย just have toย ask. You have said clearly that NATO expansion eastward is aย violation ofย theย promise you were all made inย theย 1990s. It is aย threat toย your country. Right before you sent troops into Ukraine theย Vice-President ofย theย United States spoke atย theย Security Conference andย encouraged theย President ofย Ukraine toย join NATO. Do you think that was anย effort toย provoke you into military action?
Vladimir Putin: Iย repeat once again, we have repeatedly, repeatedly proposed toย seek aย solution toย theย problems that arose inย Ukraine after theย 2014 coup dโetat through peaceful means. But no one listened toย us. Andย moreover, theย Ukrainian leaders who were under theย complete US control, suddenly declared that they would not comply with theย Minsk agreements, they disliked everything there, andย continued military activity inย that territory.
Andย inย parallel, that territory was being exploited byย NATO military structures under theย guise ofย various personnel training andย retraining centers. They essentially began toย create bases there. That’s all.
Ukraine announced that theย Russians were (aย law was adopted) aย non-titular nationality, while passing laws that limit theย rights ofย non-titular nationalities inย Ukraine. Ukraine, having received all these southeastern territories asย aย gift from theย Russian people, suddenly announced that theย Russians were aย non-titular nationality inย that territory. Is it normal? All this put together led toย theย decision toย end theย war that neo-Nazis started inย Ukraine inย 2014.
Tucker Carlson: Do you think Zelensky has theย freedom toย negotiate theย settlement toย this conflict?
Vladimir Putin: Iย donโt know theย details, ofย course itโs difficult forย me toย judge, but Iย believe he has, inย any case, he used toย have. His father fought against theย fascists, Nazis during World War II, Iย once talked toย him about this. Iย said: โVolodya, what are you doing? Why are you supporting neo-Nazis inย Ukraine today, while your father fought against fascism? He was aย front-line soldier.โ Iย will not tell you what he answered, this is aย separate topic, andย Iย think itโs incorrect forย me toย do so.
But asย toย theย freedom ofย choiceย โ why not? He came toย power onย theย expectations ofย Ukrainian people that he would lead Ukraine toย peace. He talked about this, it was thanks toย this that he won theย election overwhelmingly. But then, when he came toย power, inย myย opinion, he realized two things: firstly, it is better not toย clash with neo-Nazis andย nationalists, because they are aggressive andย very active, you can expect anything from them, andย secondly, theย US-led West supports them andย will always support those who antagonize with Russiaย โ it is beneficial andย safe. So he took theย relevant position, despite promising his people toย end theย war inย Ukraine. He deceived his voters.
Tucker Carlson: But do you think atย this pointย โ asย ofย February 2024ย โ he has theย latitude, theย freedom toย speak with you orย government directly, which would clearly help his country orย theย world? Can he do that, do you think?
Vladimir Putin: Why not? He considers himself head ofย state, he won theย elections. Although we believe inย Russia that theย coup dโetat is theย primary source ofย power forย everything that happened after 2014, andย inย this sense, even todayโs government is flawed. But he considers himself theย president, andย he is recognized byย theย United States, all ofย Europe andย practically theย rest ofย theย world inย such aย capacityย โ why not? He can.
We negotiated with Ukraine inย Istanbul, we agreed, he was aware ofย this. Moreover, theย negotiation group leader, Mr. Arakhamia is his last name, Iย believe, still heads theย faction ofย theย ruling party, theย party ofย theย President inย theย Rada. He still heads theย Presidential faction inย theย Rada, theย countryโs parliament, he still sits there. He even put his preliminary signature onย theย document Iย am telling you about. But then he publicly stated toย theย whole world: โWe were ready toย sign this document, but Mr. Johnson, then theย Prime Minister ofย Great Britain, came andย dissuaded us from doing this saying it was better toย fight Russia. They would give everything needed forย us toย return what was lost during theย clashes with Russia. Andย we agreed with this proposal.โ Look, his statement has been published. He said this publicly.
Can they return toย this orย not? Theย question is: do they want it orย not?
Further on, President ofย Ukraine issued aย decree prohibiting negotiations with us. Let him cancel that decree andย thatโs it. We have never refused negotiations indeed. We hear all theย time: is Russia ready? Yes, we have not refused! It was them who publicly refused. Well, let him cancel his decree andย enter into negotiations. We have never refused.
Andย theย fact that they obeyed theย demand orย persuasion ofย Mr. Johnson, theย former Prime Minister ofย Great Britain, seems ridiculous andย very sad toย me. Because, asย Mr. Arakhamia put it: โWe could have stopped these hostilities, this war aย year andย aย half ago already. But theย British persuaded us, andย we refused this.โ Where is Mr. Johnson now? Andย theย war continues.
Tucker Carlson: That is aย good question. Why did he do that?
Vladimir Putin: Hell knows. Iย don’t understand it myself. There was aย general starting point. Forย some reason, everyone had theย illusion that Russia could be defeated onย theย battlefield. Because ofย arrogance, because ofย aย pure heart, but not because ofย aย great mind.
Tucker Carlson: You have described theย connection between Russia andย Ukraine; you have described Russia itself, aย couple ofย times asย Orthodoxย โ that is central toย your understanding ofย Russia. What does that mean forย you? You are aย Cristian leader byย your own description. So what effect does that have onย you?
Vladimir Putin: You know, asย Iย already mentioned, inย 988 Prince Vladimir himself was baptized following theย example ofย his grandmother, Princess Olga, andย then he baptized his squad, andย then gradually, over theย course ofย several years, he baptized all theย Rus. It was aย lengthy processย โ from pagans toย Christians, it took many years. But inย theย end, this Orthodoxy, Eastern Christianity, deeply rooted itself inย theย consciousness ofย theย Russian people.
When Russia expanded andย absorbed other nations who profess Islam, Buddhism andย Judaism, Russia has always been very loyal toย those people who profess other religions. This is her strength. This is absolutely clear.
Andย theย fact is that theย main postulates, main values are very similar, not toย say theย same, inย all world religions Iโve just mentioned andย which are theย traditional religions ofย theย Russian Federation, Russia. Byย theย way, Russian authorities were always very careful about theย culture andย religion ofย those peoples who came into theย Russian Empire. This, inย myย opinion, forms theย basis ofย both security andย stability ofย theย Russian statehoodย โ all theย peoples inhabiting Russia basically consider it their Motherland.
If, say, people move over toย you orย toย Europe from Latin Americaย โ anย even clearer andย more understandable exampleย โ people come, but yet they have come toย you orย toย European countries from their historical homeland. Andย people who profess different religions inย Russia consider Russia their Motherland, they have no other Motherland. We are together, this is one big family. Andย our traditional values are very similar. Iโve just mentioned one big family, but everyone has his/hers own family, andย this is theย basis ofย our society. Andย if we say that theย Motherland andย theย family are specifically connected with each other, it is indeed theย case, since it is impossible toย ensure aย normal future forย our children andย our families unless we ensure aย normal, sustainable future forย theย entire country, forย theย Motherland. That is why patriotic sentiment is so strong inย Russia.
Tucker Carlson: Can Iย say, theย one way inย which religions are different is that Christianity is specifically aย non-violent religion. Jesus says โTurn theย other cheek, donโt killโ. How can aย leader who has toย kill, ofย any country, how can aย leader be aย Christian? How do you reconcile that toย yourself?
Vladimir Putin: It is very easy: when it comes toย protecting oneself andย oneโs family, oneโs homeland. We wonโt attack anyone.
When did theย developments inย Ukraine start? Since theย coup d’etat andย theย hostilities inย Donbass began, thatโs when they started. Andย we are protecting our people, ourselves, our homeland andย our future.
Asย forย religion inย general.
You know, itโs not about external manifestations, itโs not about going toย church every day orย banging your head onย theย floor. It is inย theย heart. Andย our culture is so human-oriented. Dostoevsky, who is very well known inย theย West asย theย genius ofย Russian culture, Russian literature, spoke aย lot about this, about theย Russian soul.
After all, Western society is more pragmatic. Russian people think more about theย eternal, about moral values. Iย donโt know, maybe you wonโt agree with me, but Western culture is more pragmatic after all.
Iโm not saying this is bad, it makes it possible forย todayโs โgolden billionโ toย achieve good success inย production, even inย science, andย so on. There’s nothing wrong with that, I’m just saying that we kind ofย look theย same, but our minds are built aย little differently.
Tucker Carlson: So do you see theย supernatural atย work? Asย you look out across whatโs happening inย theย world now, do you see God atย work? Do you ever think toย yourself: these are forces that are not human?
Vladimir Putin: No, toย be honest, Iย don’t think so. Myย opinion is that theย development ofย theย world community is inย accordance with theย inherent laws, andย those laws are what they are. It’s always been this way inย theย history ofย mankind. Some nations andย countries rose, became stronger andย more numerous, andย then left theย international stage, losing theย status they had accustomed to. There is probably no need forย me toย give examples, but we could start with Genghis Khan andย theย Horde conquerors, theย Golden Horde, andย then end with theย Roman Empire.
It seems that there has never been anything like theย Roman Empire inย theย history ofย mankind. Nevertheless, theย potential ofย theย barbarians gradually grew, asย did their population. Inย general, theย barbarians were getting stronger andย began toย develop economically, asย we would say today. This eventually led toย theย collapse ofย theย Roman Empire andย theย regime imposed byย theย Romans. However, it took five centuries forย theย Roman Empire toย fall apart. Theย difference with what is happening now is that all theย processes ofย change are happening atย aย much faster pace than inย Roman times.
Tucker Carlson: So when does theย AI empire start do you think?
Vladimir Putin: (Laughing) You are asking increasingly more complicated questions. Toย answer them, you need toย be anย expert inย big numbers, big data andย AI.
Mankind is currently facing many threats. Due toย genetic researches, it is now possible toย create aย superhuman, aย specialized human beingย โ aย genetically engineered athlete, scientist, military man.
There are reports that Elon Musk has already had aย chip implanted inย theย human brain inย theย USA.
Tucker Carlson: What do you think ofย that?
Vladimir Putin: Well, Iย think thereโs no stopping Elon Musk, he will do asย he sees fit. Nevertheless, you need toย find some common ground with him, search forย ways toย persuade him. Iย think heโs aย smart person, Iย truly believe he is. So you need toย reach anย agreement with him because this process needs toย be formalized andย subjected toย certain rules.
Humanity has toย consider what is going toย happen due toย theย newest developments inย genetics orย inย AI. One can make anย approximate prediction ofย what will happen. Once mankind felt anย existential threat coming from nuclear weapons, all nuclear nations began toย come toย terms with one another since they realized that negligent use ofย nuclear weaponry could drive humanity toย extinction.
It is impossible toย stop research inย genetics orย AI today, just asย it was impossible toย stop theย use ofย gunpowder back inย theย day. But asย soon asย we realize that theย threat comes from unbridled andย uncontrolled development ofย AI, orย genetics, orย any other fields, theย time will come toย reach anย international agreement onย how toย regulate these things.
Tucker Carlson: Iย appreciate all theย time youโve given us. Iย just want toย ask you one last question andย itโs about someone who is very famous inย theย United States, probably not here. Evan Gershkovich who is theย Wall Street Journal reporter, he is 32 andย heโs been inย prison forย almost aย year. This is aย huge story inย theย United States andย Iย just want toย ask you directly without getting into details ofย your version ofย what happened, if asย aย sign ofย your decency youโll be willing toย release him toย us andย weโll bring him back toย theย United States?
Vladimir Putin: We have done so many gestures ofย goodwill out ofย decency that Iย think we have run out ofย them. We have never seen anyone reciprocate toย us inย aย similar manner. However, inย theory, we can say that we do not rule out that we can do that if our partners take reciprocal steps.
When Iย talk about theย โpartnersโ, I, first ofย all, refer toย special services. Special services are inย contact with one another, they are talking about theย matter inย question. There is no taboo toย settle theย issue. We are willing toย solve it, but there are certain terms being discussed via special services channels. Iย believe anย agreement can be reached.
Tucker Carlson: So, typically, Iย mean, this stuff has happened for, obviously, centuries. One country catches other spy within its borders andย trades it forย one ofย its own intel guys inย other country. Iย think what makes it, andย itโs not myย business, but what makes it different is that this guy is obviously not aย spy, he is aย kid andย maybe he was breaking aย law inย some way but he is not aย superspy andย everybody knows that andย he has been held hostage andย exchange, which is true, with respect, itโs true andย everyone knows itโs true. So maybe he is inย aย different category, maybe itโs not fair toย ask forย somebody else inย exchange forย letting him out. Maybe it degrades Russia toย do that.
Vladimir Putin: You know, you can give different interpretations toย what constitutes aย โspyโ, but there are certain things provided byย law. If aย person gets secret information, andย does that inย aย conspiratorial manner, then this is qualified asย espionage. Andย that is exactly what he was doing. He was receiving classified, confidential information, andย he did it covertly. Maybe he had been implicated inย that, someone could have dragged him into that, maybe he did that out ofย carelessness, orย onย his own initiative. Considering theย sheer facts, this is qualified asย espionage. Theย fact has been proven, asย he was caught red-handed when he was receiving this information. If it had been some far-fetched excuse, some fabrication, something not proven, it would have been aย different story then. But he was caught red-handed when he was secretly getting confidential information. What is it, then?
Tucker Carlson: But are you suggesting he was working forย theย US government orย NATO? Orย he was just aย reporter who was given material he wasnโt supposed toย have? Those seem like very different, very different things.
Vladimir Putin: Iย donโt know who he was working for. But Iย would like toย reiterate that getting classified information inย secret is called espionage, andย he was working forย theย U.S. special services, some other agencies. Iย donโt think that he was working forย Monaco, asย Monaco is hardly interested inย getting that information. It is up toย theย special services toย come toย anย agreement. Some groundwork has been laid. There are people who, inย our view, are not connected with special services.
Let me tell you aย story about aย person serving aย sentence inย anย allied country ofย theย U.S. That person, due toย patriotic sentiments, eliminated aย bandit inย one ofย theย European capitals. During theย events inย theย Caucasus, do you know what he [bandit] was doing? Iย donโt want toย say that, but Iย will do it anyway. He was laying our soldiers, taken prisoner, onย theย road andย then he drove his car over their heads. What kind ofย aย person is that? Can he be even called aย human? But there was aย patriot who eliminated him inย one ofย theย European capitals. Whether he did that ofย his own volition orย not, that is aย different question.
Tucker Carlson: Evan Gershkovich, thatโs aย completely different, Iย mean, this is aย thirty-two year old newspaper reporter.
Vladimir Putin: He committed something different.
Tucker Carlson: He is just aย journalist
Vladimir Putin: He is not just aย journalist, Iย reiterate, he is aย journalist who was secretly getting confidential information.
Yes, it is different, but still, Iย am talking about other people who are essentially controlled byย theย U.S. authorities wherever they are serving aย sentence. There is anย ongoing dialogue between theย special services. This has toย be resolved inย aย calm, responsible andย professional manner. They are keeping inย touch, so let them do their work.
Iย do not rule out that theย person you referred to, Mister Gershkovich, may return toย his motherland. Byย theย end ofย theย day, it does not make any sense toย keep him inย prison inย Russia. We want theย U.S. special services toย think about how they can contribute toย achieving theย goals our special services are pursuing. We are ready toย talk. Moreover, theย talks are underway, andย there have been many successful examples ofย these talks crowned with success. Probably this is going toย be crowned with success asย well, but we have toย come toย anย agreement.
Tucker Carlson: Iย hope youโll let him out. Mister President, thank you!
Vladimir Putin: Iย also want him toย return toย his homeland atย last. Iย am absolutely sincere. But let me say once again, theย dialogue continues. Theย more public we render things ofย this nature, theย more difficult it becomes toย resolve them. Everything has toย be done inย aย calm manner.
Tucker Carlson: Iย wonder if thatโs true with theย war though also, Iย mean, Iย guess Iย want toย ask one more question which is, andย maybe you donโt want toย say so forย strategic reasons, but are you worried that whatโs happening inย Ukraine could lead toย something much larger andย much more horrible andย how motivated are you just toย call theย US government andย say โletโs come toย termsโ?
Vladimir Putin: Iย already said that we did not refuse toย talk. We are willing toย negotiate. It is theย Western side, andย Ukraine is obviously aย satellite state ofย theย U.S. It is evident. Iย do not want you toย take it asย if Iย am looking forย aย strong word orย anย insult, but we both understand what is happening.
Theย financial support, 72 billion U.S. dollars, was provided. Germany ranks second, then other European countries come. Dozens ofย billions ofย U.S. dollars are go toย Ukraine. There is aย huge influx ofย weapons.
Inย this case you should tell theย current Ukrainian leadership toย stop andย come toย theย negotiating table, rescind this absurd decree. We did not refuse.
Tucker Carlson: Well, sure, you have already said itย โ Iย didnโt think you meant it asย anย insultย โ because you have already said, correctly, it’s been reported that Ukraine was prevented from negotiating peace settlement byย theย former British prime-minister acting onย behalf ofย theย Biden administration. Ofย course, it’s our satellite, big countries control small countries, that’s not new. Andย that is why Iย asked about dealing directly with theย Biden administration, which is making these decisions, not president Zelensky ofย Ukraine.
Vladimir Putin: Well, if theย Zelensky administration inย Ukraine refused toย negotiate, Iย assume that they did it under theย instruction from Washington. If Washington believes it toย be theย wrong decision, let it abandon it, let it find aย delicate excuse so that no one is insulted, let it come up with aย way out. It was not us who made this decision, it was them, so let them go back onย it. That is it.
However, they made theย wrong decision andย now we have toย look forย aย way out ofย this situation, toย correct their mistakes. They did it so let them correct it themselves. We support this.
Tucker Carlson: So, Iย just want toย make sure Iย am not misunderstanding what you are sayingย โ andย Iย don’t think that Iย amย โ Iย think you are saying you want aย negotiated settlement toย what’s happening inย Ukraine.
Vladimir Putin: Right. Andย we made it, we prepared aย huge document inย Istanbul that was initialed byย theย head ofย theย Ukrainian delegation. He affixed his signature toย some ofย theย provisions, not toย all ofย it. He put his signature andย then he himself said: โWe were ready toย sign it andย theย war would have been over long ago, eighteen months ago. However, Prime Minister Johnson came, talked us out ofย it andย we missed that chance.โ Well, you missed it, you made aย mistake, let them get back toย that, that is all. Why do we have toย bother ourselves andย correct somebody elseโs mistakes?
Iย know one can say it is our mistake, it was us who intensified theย situation andย decided toย put anย end toย theย war that started inย 2014 inย Donbas, asย Iย have already said, byย means ofย weapons. Let me get back toย further inย history, Iย already told you this, we were just discussing it. Let us go back toย 1991 when we were promised that NATO would not be expanded, toย 2008 when theย doors toย NATO opened, toย theย Declaration ofย State Sovereignty ofย Ukraine declaring Ukraine aย neutral state. Let us go back toย theย fact that NATO andย US military bases started toย appear onย theย territory ofย Ukraine creating threats forย us. Let us go back toย coup d’รฉtat inย Ukraine inย 2014. It is pointless though, isnโt it? We may go back andย forth endlessly. But they stopped negotiations. Is it aย mistake? Yes. Correct it. We are ready. What else is needed?
Tucker Carlson: Do you think it is too humiliating atย this point forย NATO toย accept Russian control ofย what was two years ago Ukrainian territory?
Vladimir Putin: Iย said let them think how toย do it with dignity. There are options if there is aย will.
Up until now there has been theย uproar andย screaming about inflicting aย strategic defeat onย Russia onย theย battlefield. Now they are apparently coming toย realize that it is difficult toย achieve, if possible atย all. Inย myย opinion, it is impossible byย definition, it is never going toย happen. It seems toย me that now those who are inย power inย theย West have come toย realize this asย well. If so, if theย realization has set in, they have toย think what toย do next. We are ready forย this dialogue.
Tucker Carlson: Would you be willing toย say, โCongratulations, NATO, you won?โ Andย just keep theย situation where it is now?
Vladimir Putin: You know, it is aย subject matter forย theย negotiations no one is willing toย conduct or, toย put it more accurately, they are willing but do not know how toย do it. Iย know they want. It is not just Iย see it but Iย know they do want it but they are struggling toย understand how toย do it. They have driven theย situation toย theย point where we are at. It is not us who have done that, it is our partners, opponents who have done that. Well, now let them think how toย reverse theย situation. We are not against it.
It would be funny if it were not so sad. This endless mobilization inย Ukraine, theย hysteria, theย domestic problemsย โ sooner orย later it all will result inย anย agreement. You know, this will probably sound strange given theย current situation but theย relations between theย two peoples will be rebuilt anyway. It will take aย lot ofย time but they will heal.
Iย will give you very unusual examples. There is aย combat encounter onย theย battlefield, here is aย specific example: Ukrainian soldiers got encircled (this is anย example from real life), our soldiers were shouting toย them: โThere is no chance! Surrender yourselves! Come out andย you will be alive!โ Suddenly theย Ukrainian soldiers were screaming from there inย Russian, perfect Russian, saying: โRussians do not surrender!โ andย all ofย them perished. They still identify themselves asย Russian.
What is happening is, toย aย certain extent, anย element ofย aย civil war. Everyone inย theย West thinks that theย Russian people have been split byย hostilities forever. No. They will be reunited. Theย unity is still there.
Why are theย Ukranian authorities dismantling theย Ukranian Orthodox Church? Because it brings together not only theย territory, it brings together our souls. No one will be able toย separate theย soul.
Shall we end here orย there is anything else?
Tucker Carlson: Thank you, Mr. President.
Discover more from The Libertarian Alliance
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.




